Women are at the forefront of challenging extremism in Idlib
Leila Al Shami.
This was originally published at Chatham House. Here is a longer, un-edited version.
In May, SMART News Agency, an oppositional media site, released a video report addressing educational and administrative corruption at Idlib University. The University is under the governance of the Syrian Salvation Government, the civil authority wing of the powerful hard-line Islamist group Hayaat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) dominant in much of the rebel-held province. One of the interviewees was a young mother named Fatima Idris. Displaced from Homs to Idlib, Fatima’s a student at the university’s Media Institute. Her outspoken criticisms prompted her arrest by HTS, sparking outrage from activists and protests from female studentsStudents of the Free Aleppo University protest detention of Fatima Idris, May 2018: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05xNBz6t3F8. Fatima was released from detention two weeks later, possibly as a result of public pressure. Her case serves as an example of the continuing local resistance to authoritarian armed groups, of which women are often at the forefront.
Idlib’s liberation from the Assad regime brought an explosion in creative attempts by the local population to self-govern their communities as state institutions withdrew. Civil society based on inclusive, participatory values thrived. Yet the practices of hard-line militant groups have threatened these hard won freedoms. HTS (formally al-Qaeda-linked Nusra) has attempted to take over civil governance institutions and control basic service provision and border crossings, leading to vastly increased consumer costs for services and goods. It’s clamped down on civil society activists and organisations. Clashes between HTS and Jabhat Tahrir Suria (JTS), a coalition which comprises militant Salafist groups Nureddin al-Zinki and Ahrar al-Sham, have further increased the hostility of Idlib’s population. The rebel infighting has resulted in numerous civilian casualties as well as a string of politically motivated arrests and assassinations. According to 24CR, a group which monitors civilian resistance to extremist groups, this has resulted in “extreme public outrage to the extent that the local civilians now consider the aforementioned parties as occupation forces and as authoritarian as the Assad forces.”24CR, ‘The Enemy Brothers’ War in Idlib’, June 2018, https://24cr.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/The-Enemy-Brothers-War.pdf
Yet the presence of a vibrant civil society in Idlib has allowed the population to challenge HTS’s dominance over civil affairs and protect people’s rights. Continuing protests have been held against HTS which in some cases have resulted in their expulsion from communities, as was the case in Saraqeb. Over 400 local activists established al-Idlibi House in order to coordinate opposition to HTS’s control and call for the de-militarization of their communities, organizing media campaigns and public demonstrations.Julia Taleb, ‘Syrians roll back extremism in Idlib without military intervention’, 23 May 2017 https://wagingnonviolence.org/feature/syrians-roll-back-extremism-idlib/ Many local councils (civil administrative units governing liberated areas) have issued statements rejecting the group’s authority. According to a recent report on Idlib’s civil resistance (citing a study conducted in July 2017), “77% of those surveyed disagreed with HTS and other Salafist groups in Idlib, 73% rejected HTS-affiliated councils in Idlib. Nearly all of them believed HTS was against the aims of the revolution.”The Syria Campaign and Peace Direct, ‘Idlib Lives: The untold story of heroes’, May 2018 https://idliblives.org/
Women have been disproportionately affected by HTS’s attempts to regulate civilian life and impose a new dictatorship. Some edicts, ostensibly issued in the name of Sharia Law and enforced by HTS’s religious police known as ‘Sawid Al Khayr’, include strict dress codes for women, preventing the mixing of males and females on buses, and requiring widows to move in with a Mahram (close male relative). Such measures have also prompted demonstrations by the local community. In Farouq camp for widows in northern Idlib, women protested against the decision to impose a Mahram on them.Enab Baladi ‘Widows object to the decision of the “Salvation Government” to live with a Mahram’, 19 December 2017, in Arabic https://www.enabbaladi.net/archives/192498?so=related In Idlib city women formed volunteer groups which conducted house visits to women to counter extremist views and oppose female preachers who were imposing compliance with Sharia law. Such activities were successful in expelling problematic female preachers from the community.Julia Taleb, ‘Syrians roll back extremism in Idlib without military intervention’, 23 May 2017 https://wagingnonviolence.org/feature/syrians-roll-back-extremism-idlib/
Women’s resistance to extremism requires women’s organization, and this can pose a challenge in more conservative and traditional communities where women’s role is often relegated to the private sphere. There are over 150 local councils in Idlib province, many of which have had their members democratically elected in the first such elections in over four decades of Assadist rule. Whilst women are often denied leadership roles on local councils, Idlib’s local council has established a women’s empowerment office which works to raise women’s awareness on social and political issues and support her increased involvement in public affairs. In a video report produced by the Syrian women’s advocacy campaign Liberated-T, women involved in the local council describe the challenges they face from men in their community. According to one interviewee, “Women’s empowerment in our society is very difficult. The violence and oppression women are subjected to is a huge obstacle against her participation in society. We are moving in small steps hoping to reach a point where women can fully participate.”Liberated-T, ‘Local Council Women’, December 2017 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3958a3RPcNU
Towards this end women’s centers have also been established. The Syrian-led NGO Women Now for Development has two centres in Idlib, one of which runs an Internet café for women. They run leadership programmes for women and many of their graduates have gone on to work in local councils. Their first centre in Idlib was established in Maarat al-Numan in 2014 and is run by Muzna al-Jundi, a 30-year-old mother of two and graduate in technical engineering. In 2016 the centre participated in preparations for the local council election.Liberated –T, ‘Muzna Al Jundi’ June 2018 http://www.liberated-t.com/?p=1311&lang=en In Kafranbel the Mazaya center was set up in June 2013 by Ghalya Rahal in order to teach vocational skills to women allowing them to achieve financial independence, to hold discussions on women’s rights issues, and to challenge the increasing threats posed by radical Islamist groups.Alaa Nassar and Alice Al Maleh, ‘Civil society activist defies war and Islamist intimidation in her efforts to empower women’, Syria Direct, 25 April 2018, http://syriadirect.org/news/civil-society-activist-defies-war-and-islamist-intimidation-in-her-efforts-to-empower-women/#.WuMjbjJqbP8.twitter Today the Mazaya Organization runs eight centres in Idlib province as well as medical clinics and a women’s magazine. Such activities have provoked the ire of extremists. On 10 November 2014, the centre was subjected to an arson attack by an unknown group, and a short time later Ghalya survived an assassination attempt. The centre was previously raided and damaged by Jabhat al-Nusra militants in January 2014.
The Syrian revolution provided greater opportunities for women to work outside of the home. This was partly due to conditions of war where men were often absent and unable to provide for their families. The White Helmets civil defence force contains many female volunteers and operates women’s centres in Idlib which provide women’s medical services as well as training in first aid and nursing. Most of the employees at the Union of Revolutionary Bureaus are women and they have provided media training to female citizen journalists. One of the most popular local radio stations in Idlib, Radio Fresh, has also been in conflict with radical Islamist groups. When Nusra militants prohibited music and female broadcasters, ostensibly for contravening Islam, the radio station broadcast animal noises and digitally reworked women’s voices to sound like men in a sarcastic act of defiance. The radio’s offices have been raided by both Nusra and ISIS, and activists involved have been subjected to assassination attempts and arrests. They continue to broadcast.
The existence of extremist militant groups in Idlib province is the justification given by the regime and its Russian ally for continuing aerial assault. Yet these airstrikes, which usually target residential areas and vital civilian infrastructure, and which maim and kill men, women and children, create the chaos and despair in which extremist groups thrive. The presence of such groups also provides the rationale for withdrawal of donor funding to civil society organizations over fears it may end up in the wrong hands. Yet the resistance to extremism comes most successfully from local communities which have strong civil society networks and, critically, where women whose rights are most under threat actively participate. A serious anti-extremism policy would require an end to the bombing of civilians, and the continuation of funds and support for women’s civil society groups.
Featured Image: Women and girls at Farouq camp, northern Idlib protest against HTS. Source: Enab Baladi
 24CR, ‘The Enemy Brothers’ War in Idlib’, June 2018, https://24cr.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/The-Enemy-Brothers-War.pdf
 Julia Taleb, ‘Syrians roll back extremism in Idlib without military intervention’, 23 May 2017 https://wagingnonviolence.org/feature/syrians-roll-back-extremism-idlib/
 Enab Baladi ‘Widows object to the decision of the “Salvation Government” to live with a Mahram’, 19 December 2017, in Arabic https://www.enabbaladi.net/archives/192498?so=related
 Julia Taleb, as above.
 Alaa Nassar and Alice Al Maleh, ‘Civil society activist defies war and Islamist intimidation in her efforts to empower women’, Syria Direct, 25 April 2018, http://syriadirect.org/news/civil-society-activist-defies-war-and-islamist-intimidation-in-her-efforts-to-empower-women/#.WuMjbjJqbP8.twitter
|↑1||Students of the Free Aleppo University protest detention of Fatima Idris, May 2018: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05xNBz6t3F8|
|↑2||24CR, ‘The Enemy Brothers’ War in Idlib’, June 2018, https://24cr.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/The-Enemy-Brothers-War.pdf|
|↑3, ↑6||Julia Taleb, ‘Syrians roll back extremism in Idlib without military intervention’, 23 May 2017 https://wagingnonviolence.org/feature/syrians-roll-back-extremism-idlib/|
|↑4||The Syria Campaign and Peace Direct, ‘Idlib Lives: The untold story of heroes’, May 2018 https://idliblives.org/|
|↑5||Enab Baladi ‘Widows object to the decision of the “Salvation Government” to live with a Mahram’, 19 December 2017, in Arabic https://www.enabbaladi.net/archives/192498?so=related|
|↑7||Liberated-T, ‘Local Council Women’, December 2017 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3958a3RPcNU|
|↑8||Liberated –T, ‘Muzna Al Jundi’ June 2018 http://www.liberated-t.com/?p=1311&lang=en|
|↑9||Alaa Nassar and Alice Al Maleh, ‘Civil society activist defies war and Islamist intimidation in her efforts to empower women’, Syria Direct, 25 April 2018, http://syriadirect.org/news/civil-society-activist-defies-war-and-islamist-intimidation-in-her-efforts-to-empower-women/#.WuMjbjJqbP8.twitter|